Okay, so you’re about to write a piece of music for some video. The first question you ask yourself is major or minor. What direction do you want to go in? And do you want the entire score to be major or minor or are you going to mix it up? Make no mistake about it, the key you choose to score in will have a major impact (pun intended) on how the video itself is perceived and accepted by the public.
Now, you could go by the age old standard of happy = major and sad = minor and that’ll work just fine for most things. But what if the video isn’t happy or sad?
Take this as an example. The video is a scene of the Romans getting ready to attack. They are in formation, thousands strong. Is this happy or sad? Well, if you’re on the receiving end of their attack, you’re going to be pretty sad once you get your butt kicked into next Tuesday. Of course if you’re the Romans, you’re going to be in celebration mode once the whole thing is over.
Or will you be?
Ah, therein lies the whole rub. At the moment in time during the video where you see the Romans lined up getting ready to attack, this is kind of like that darn cat that they’re always talking about. The outcome, at this point in time, can be either good or bad for the Romans. There is no way of knowing which it will be until you view the rest of the video.
But then that brings up another issue. Do we want the audience to know beforehand how things are going to turn out? If you start the scene in the minor the audience is going to expect the battle to end badly for the Romans. If you start it in a majestic major, they’re going to expect victory.
This is a sticky wicket. If you toss one at them and it turns out to be the opposite, they’re going to feel mislead and deceived. That’s not good for business. On the other hand, if you give them what they expect as a turnout, well, the mystery kind of goes out the window.
Wait a minute. That’s it! The mystery. The music doesn’t have to be major OR minor. It can be atonal. Heck, you can start the piece by playing a single note. Maybe play octaves afterwards. Keep them guessing. Don’t give them the payoff until you’re pretty sure they’re going to figure it out anyway.
Okay, I took a very extreme case where you want to put a little mystery into things. The master of mystery and suspense was Bernard Herrmann. Listen to stuff from Hitchcock or even Perry Mason. His stuff is legendary. You never knew exactly what was going to go down.
And that is great film scoring.
But let’s move away from the extreme cases and focus on the more common for now.
Determining an overall tone for a video should be fairly straight forward. What is going on in the scene? There are many emotions in life. A good video will convey those emotions even without the underscoring. It’s not hard to look at two people kissing and holding each other tightly to know what’s going on.
But what lead up to the kiss? Ah, that makes all the difference in the world. You’re going to score the actual kiss itself differently depending on how the two kissing got there.
For example, let’s say that the scene starts out with a man and a woman in the bedroom. The man is standing watching the woman slowly begin to unbutton her blouse. Can you imagine what’s playing in the background? A stereotypical way to handle this would be the sexy sax, maybe over some jazz like piano chords.
But what if the scene went something like this?
A man rushes into the hospital having seen his wife’s car on the road in a terrible accident. The car is totaled. It doesn’t look like anybody could have possibly survived it. The man is frantic and dashes to his car and drives to the nearest hospital. He rushes in and finds his wife talking to the doctor. She’s okay. She’s not hurt. His eyes light up as he sees her. She turns and sees him. They look and smile at each other and then run into each other’s arms.
If you’re hearing sexy sax music for the scene above then there is something seriously wrong with your wiring. This calls for a dramatic orchestral score with strings accenting the embrace and kiss that just lights up the whole screen.
“As Time Goes By” says that a kiss is just a kiss. But in the movies, a kiss is not just a kiss. The context of that kiss will make all the difference in the world as far as how the scene is going to be scored. A kiss goodbye could be scored in the minor, especially if it’s a husband and wife parting for the last time.
That’s why, many times, you’re going to have to watch the entire video to determine how you’re going to score each individual scene. The overall atmosphere of the video could very well back you into a corner as far as what you can and can’t do. If the film is a comedy, I don’t care how sad one part of it may be, you’re not going to be able to score it like you would for a serious film. Of course you throw all caution to the wind and go totally over the top and turn the comedy into an all out farce. Yeah, music can do that.
We could discuss this subject until hell freezes over and we’ll never be able to come up with answers for every possible situation. That’s the beautiful thing about music. It is so wide open that it is virtually unlimited as to what can be done. The key is knowing when to do what.
In some cases, that’s easier said than done.
For The Love Of Music,
Steven “Wags” Wagenheim