I know this article is going to ruffle a lot of feathers. A lot of people are under the impression that in order to make it in the music business your stuff has to be of high quality. If only that were true. A lot of people starving right now would be making a living and a lot of big stars would be on the streets begging for scraps. The truth is, quality has very little to do with how successful one is with his music.
But why?
Okay, before I answer that, let me ask you a question. Why is it that very few pop music stars have careers longer than a few years? Even superstars reach a point where their music doesn’t sell anymore.
Paul McCartney just turned 72 today. Why is it that I can’t remember the last time he had a number 1 song? In fact, his last big world wide hit was “No More Lonely Nights” in 1984. that’s 30 years ago.
Did Paul McCartney suddenly forget how to write a quality song? Somehow, I don’t think so. If anything, after all these years, McCartney should be writing the best music of his life as he has so much life experience to tap into.
And if you listen to some of his recent albums, he’s written some amazing music including the haunting “The End Of The End” from “Memory Almost Full” released in 2007. While the album sold well (over 2 million copies) there wasn’t one hit single from it. And “The End Of The End” wasn’t even released as a single.
Point is, where are all the big hits that McCartney churned out with regularity back in the 70s like “Uncle Albert”, “Live And Let Die”, “My Love”, “Let ‘Em In” (which was really a horrible song) and on and on and on?
If “Let ‘Em In” is a quality song, I’m digging into my catalog of crap I wrote in the 80s and sending it to every tone deaf publisher I can get a hold of.
An artist or song is popular, not so much because of the quality of the song or artist itself but because of intangibles that are very hard to describe in any meaningful way.
In short, the taste of the general public is very subjective and very fickle. The public gets tired of things very fast. So while the quality of the music might be the same, the outcome could be totally different.
A perfect example of this is the group Boston. Each album sounded exactly the same as the one before it. But they never duplicated the success that they had with their debut album that sold 17x platinum. By their 4th album, which took 18 years to release after their first album with only 2 in between, they barely made it to platinum status and their last 2 albums didn’t sell at all. This is a group that had a 37 year career with only 4 selling albums. Personally, I was tired of them after the second album.
That’s the key word…tired. Especially since EVERYTHING they did sounded the same. They had a formula, the beat it to death and eventually it killed them.
What about the awful music that became chart toppers? Too many examples to point out so I won’t bother. One just needs to listen to “I’m Too Sexy” or the more recent “Friday” to find out how bad music can become ridiculously popular, even if it’s not for the right reason.
So the question you need to ask yourself, if your a composer or performer is this.
Do you want to write good music or music that sells? The two don’t necessarily have to coexist together.
Can good music sell? Sure! Lots of good music sells. But lots of bad music sells just as well if not more. I can just about listen to the radio these days with all the crap that’s on it. The good songs are in the minority. I sometimes wonder if my chances of making it are slim to none simply because I can’t lower myself to the standards that today’s consumer has accepted as acceptable.
Regardless of what you may or may not think of today’s music and regardless of what you decide you want to do with your own music, if you want to make it in any business of music, whether it be royalty free, pop, classical or whatever, you need to tune in with what’s going on in the world today.
Me? I go to other royalty free music sites to see what kind of music is up there. I look at the genres that they cover and I listen to a good sample of the music in each genre to see what’s popular. You can’t create tracks that people want unless you know what they want. The only way to do that is through research.
What if you’re looking to make it into some form of popular music as a composer? Well, it’s pretty much the same thing. You need to do your research. That will involve listening to a lot of radio to see what’s popular today. Because stations are highly specialized today you’re going to hear a lot of the same kind of music depending on what station you’re listening to. In some parts of the world, country is very big. In other parts, dance music rules the airwaves. Make sure you’re tuned into the kind of music YOU want to create.
After that, it’s all imitation. No, not plagiarism. You don’t steal. You emulate. You’ll notice that most songs of a particular genre have certain characteristics that are carried over from song to song with the only thing really changing is the melody. If you think I’m kidding, watch that hysterical video by Axis Of Awesome about how all songs are four chords. If it wasn’t true, it wouldn’t be so funny.
Once you have the formula down, you’re half way there to having a hit. All that’s left is persistence and a little luck.
Yeah, with all that, you still need some luck.
For The Love Of Music,
Steven “Wags” Wagenheim